As the Russian imperial front dissolved, the newly declared republics of Armenia and Azerbaijan fought over Karabakh, Zangezur and Nakhchivan while communal massacres consumed mixed districts. In Baku, fighting between Bolshevik-Dashnak forces and Azerbaijani Musavatists in the 'March Days' of 1918 left thousands of Muslim civilians dead, and in September 1918 Ottoman-backed forces of the Army of Islam entered the city and killed large numbers of Armenians; estimates for each episode run from several thousand to tens of thousands and are strongly contested along national lines. In March 1920 the Armenian quarter of Shusha was destroyed and its population killed or driven out, with death estimates ranging from about 500 to 20,000. Hundreds of thousands of civilians fled in both directions, and the surviving refugee flows helped fix the ethnically separated map that Soviet delimitation formalised in 1921-23. Armenian and Azerbaijani historiographies differ sharply on sequence, responsibility and numbers for almost every episode in this period.
Armenian, Azerbaijani and Ottoman forces and local militias killed and expelled each other's civilian populations across the contested South Caucasus
No reliable census covered the period. Russian imperial estimates of 1916 and the figures used by the two short-lived republics give Armenia roughly 1.3 million - swollen by refugees from Ottoman Anatolia and then thinned by famine - and Azerbaijan about 2 million. Both are contested and unstable given the refugee movements of these years.
The lower bound reflects conservative scholarly tallies of the identifiable massacres (Baku March and September 1918, Shusha 1920, and village-level killings in Karabakh, Zangezur and Nakhchivan); the upper bound reflects the maximal claims of the Armenian and Azerbaijani national historiographies, each of which counts the other side's victims low and its own high. There was no neutral authority in the region to record deaths.
British occupation reports, Near East Relief workers and the rival republics' own commissions of inquiry recorded mass killings and the burning of Armenian and Azerbaijani quarters and villages.
Azerbaijan, Armenia