Human Conflict Project

All events · Empire, Clearance and Removal

The Semaine Sanglante and the Deportation of the Communards

1871–1880 · Europe & Northern Eurasia

Displacement Mass Killing Killing was the defining act
Displaced
4,000
Roughly 3,800-4,300 Communards were deported to New Caledonia between 1872 and 1878: the City of Paris gives about 3,800 carried in twenty convoys, the Amis de la Commune association 'près de 4 000', and the open-edited account of the penal colony 4,250. They were held either under 'simple' deportation on the Île des Pins or in a fortified enclosure on the Ducos peninsula. These are counts drawn from court-martial and colonial records, not estimates. Far more people were held than deported: the City of Paris, drawing on General Appert's official report, gives about 43,000 arrested, 46,835 individuals judged and 10,137 convicted, and the arrested were held in the camp at Satory and in the western ports, some of them aboard ships.
Killed
5,700–25,000
conflict deaths incl. combatants

Open on the interactive map →

What happened

After the Paris Commune rose against the national government in March 1871, the Versailles army entered the city on 21 May and retook it street by street in the week to 28 May, known as la semaine sanglante. Communards were killed in the fighting and in large numbers after capture, shot at improvised courts ('cours prévôtales') and, in one well-known case, against the wall of Père-Lachaise cemetery; Commune forces executed about a hundred hostages during the same week. The death toll is disputed: older estimates of 15,000-40,000 and the figure of about 20,000 still used by the City of Paris contrast with Robert Tombs's 2012 archival revision in the Historical Journal, which puts the dead at about 5,700-7,400, roughly half of them killed after the fighting. About 43,000 people were then arrested, and some two dozen military courts sitting over four years convicted 10,137, deporting some 3,800-4,300 to New Caledonia, where Louise Michel was among those held, before partial amnesty in 1879 and full amnesty in 1880. The penal colony and the colonisation of New Caledonia are covered in the entry on Kanak dispossession, which counts these political deportees within its convict figures; this entry covers the killing in Paris and the deportation itself. In 2016 the French National Assembly adopted a resolution proclaiming the rehabilitation of the victims of the repression.

Parties

The French government at Versailles and its army retook Paris from the Commune, killing thousands of Communards in the fighting and in summary executions, then tried tens of thousands before courts-martial and deported several thousand to New Caledonia

Disputed

The number killed in May 1871 is disputed: Tombs's archival count of about 6,000-7,500 is far below the 15,000-40,000 of earlier estimates and Jacques Rougerie's demographic hypothesis of up to 30,000, and reviewers such as Deluermoz and Varley accept his method but say uncounted bodies may push the toll higher.

On the death toll

The low end is Robert Tombs's 2012 revision (Historical Journal), an order-of-magnitude range of about 5,700-7,400 dead built from cemetery, hospital and municipal records, with about half killed after the fighting; Quentin Deluermoz rounds it to 6,500. The high end is the City of Paris's 2021 account, which gives 3,000-5,000 Fédérés killed in combat and about 20,000 others massacred, in line with the 'nearly 20,000' long used in histories; Varley notes Tombs himself had earlier used 25,000 and then 20,000. Higher figures exist: Deluermoz cites earlier estimates of up to 40,000 and Jacques Rougerie's argument that the fall of 180,000 in Paris's population between 1870 and 1872 could support up to 30,000 dead, and the Amis de la Commune panel gives 15,000-30,000 summary executions; Deluermoz suggests that a wide range of 6,500-20,000 is the safest. The disagreement turns on how many bodies escaped the institutional records (burned, buried outside the cemeteries or dying later of wounds). Separately, the City of Paris gives 500-800 Versailles soldiers killed and about a hundred hostages executed by the Fédérés.

Documented forms of violence

Mass KillingSummary Execution

Robert Tombs (2012) and the City of Paris's account document the killing of Communards after capture, including by improvised 'cours prévôtales' and the shootings at Père-Lachaise, and the French National Assembly's 2016 resolution refers to summary executions.

Formal findings

Movements mapped

Countries touched, on present-day borders

France, New Caledonia

Sources

← EarlierThe Criminal Tribes Acts and the Settlement of India's 'Criminal Tribes' Later →The Aceh War and the Dutch Conquest of Northern Sumatra