Human Conflict Project

All events · Empires Unmade

Soviet Punitive Psychiatry and the Special Psychiatric Hospitals

c. 1960–1989 · Europe & Northern Eurasia

Confinement
Confined
20,000
Estimates differ by an order of magnitude according to what is counted. A frequently cited figure is that at least 20,000 people were confined in psychiatric hospitals for political reasons; Anatoly Prokopenko, working from documents declassified in the 1990s, estimated about 15,000 held in the MVD-run special psychiatric hospitals specifically; and the post-Soviet Commission for Rehabilitation stated that hundreds of thousands had been unlawfully placed in psychiatric institutions, a figure that includes non-political committals. As a condition of the USSR's readmission to the World Psychiatric Association in 1989, between one and two million people were removed from psychiatric registries.
Share of the population affected
0.01%
of the population of the Soviet Union at the 1959 census, 1959

Open on the interactive map →

What happened

From the early 1960s Soviet authorities increasingly dealt with political dissent through compulsory psychiatric committal rather than criminal trial, using a broad diagnostic category, 'sluggish schizophrenia', associated with Andrei Snezhnevsky's school at the Serbsky Institute in Moscow, under which symptoms could include pessimism, poor social adaptation and conflict with authority. Those found not responsible were sent either to ordinary psychiatric hospitals or to special psychiatric hospitals run by the interior ministry, which operated as prisons; detainees and their advocates documented forced administration of drugs including sulfazine and haloperidol, beatings and indefinite confinement dependent on renouncing their views. The practice was exposed from inside the USSR by the Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes and by samizdat, and abroad by Amnesty International and Western psychiatrists; facing expulsion, the Soviet psychiatric society withdrew from the World Psychiatric Association at its 1983 Vienna congress and was readmitted in 1989 after acknowledging past abuse. The Russian Federation has acknowledged that psychiatry was used for political purposes and accepted responsibility toward the victims. Soviet-era psychiatrists and some Russian commentators have continued to argue that most committals were clinically motivated.

Parties

Soviet security organs and state psychiatrists confined dissenters, believers and would-be emigrants in psychiatric hospitals without criminal trial

Disputed

How many committals were politically motivated rather than clinical remains disputed, as does the extent to which individual psychiatrists acted under duress; Soviet authorities denied the practice throughout, and post-Soviet estimates range from around 15,000-20,000 clearly political cases to far larger totals for unlawful committal generally.

The denominator

The 1959 census recorded 208,826,650 people. The 20,000 figure is not an official statistic: it is an approximation built up from the case files compiled by the Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes, from émigré testimony, and from the partial disclosures of the late Soviet and Russian psychiatric professions.

The numerator is a cumulative estimate over three decades measured against a single-year snapshot, and it is a lower-bound reconstruction from incomplete case records rather than a count, so the resulting share is illustrative only.

Where the baseline comes from

On the death toll

There was no mass killing and no aggregate death toll exists. Deaths did occur in the special hospitals from drug regimes, beatings and neglect, and some detainees emerged with lasting psychiatric injury, but no systematic count has been produced from the archives.

Documented forms of violence

Arbitrary DetentionTorture

Compulsory confinement without trial and the punitive use of drugs and restraint were documented by Amnesty International, by the Moscow Working Commission to Investigate the Use of Psychiatry for Political Purposes and by the World Psychiatric Association's 1983 proceedings.

Countries touched, on present-day borders

Russia

Sources

This entry rests only on reference, press or open-edited sources. Treat its figures as indicative and follow the links before relying on them.
← EarlierGuatemalan Civil War and Maya Genocide Later →The Chittagong Hill Tracts: the Kaptai Dam, Settlement and Counter-Insurgency