Human Conflict Project

All events · Conquest and the Slave Trades

The Toledo Reducciones and the Potosí Mita

c. 1569–1750 · Americas

Displacement Territory Seized
Displaced
1.4 million
The general resettlement of the 1570s is usually said to have moved on the order of 1.4 million people from thousands of scattered hamlets into roughly eight hundred to a thousand new towns; Jeremy Mumford's study of the general resettlement is the standard modern account and the figures derive from the visita records compiled for Toledo's inspection, which counted tributaries rather than people. The mita quota established for Potosí required about 13,500 conscripts a year drawn from sixteen highland provinces, roughly one adult man in seven from each community serving in rotation, travelling with their families for distances of hundreds of kilometres. Both figures are administrative targets recorded in colonial legislation, not counts of people actually moved, and evasion and flight were widespread.
Share of the population affected
93%
of the indigenous population of the Viceroyalty of Peru enumerated in Viceroy Toledo's general inspection of 1570-1575, 1570

Open on the interactive map →

What happened

Between 1569 and 1581 Viceroy Francisco de Toledo carried out the largest programme of compulsory resettlement in the colonial Americas, uprooting the dispersed Andean settlement pattern and concentrating the rural population into new grid-plan towns, the reducciones, where tribute could be assessed, doctrine taught and labour drafted. In parallel he adapted the Inca institution of the mita into a rotating conscription that sent roughly 13,500 men a year, with their households, from sixteen provinces to the silver mines of Potosí and the mercury mine at Huancavelica. Conditions in the mines and refineries were lethal, though no reliable mortality series exists; the surviving records show sustained flight from mita provinces, the growth of a class of permanent migrants who had abandoned their home communities to escape the draft, and the passage of vacated community land into Spanish hands. Colonial administrators themselves recorded that the reducciones did not hold: by the end of the sixteenth century officials complained that taxpaying Indians were fleeing in growing numbers. Modern economic research has traced measurable long-run disadvantage in districts that were subject to the mita compared with adjacent districts that were not.

Parties

Viceroy Francisco de Toledo forcibly regrouped the Andean rural population into planned towns and instituted a rotating forced-labour draft to supply the silver mines of Potosí

Disputed

How many people were actually moved, and how far the demographic decline of the mita provinces should be attributed to the labour draft and the resettlement rather than to epidemics affecting the whole Andes, are both disputed.

The denominator

Toledo's visita general, the first systematic count of the Andes, enumerated roughly 1.3-1.5 million tributary Indians and their dependants across the viceroyalty; the sixteen highland provinces made liable for the Potosí mita held on the order of a million of them. The pre-conquest Andean population was far larger, with estimates from about 4 to 12 million, so this baseline is already a post-collapse figure.

The affected figure is close to the whole enumerated population because the reducciones resettled essentially everyone counted, while the mita draft that followed extended over roughly seven further generations, so the ratio measures the reach of one resettlement rather than the total number of people the programme touched over 1569-1750.

Where the baseline comes from

On the death toll

No defensible death toll exists. Mortality at Potosí and Huancavelica was notoriously high — mercury poisoning at Huancavelica, cave-ins, silicosis and cold at Potosí — and colonial critics from the seventeenth century onward wrote of millions dead, but those numbers are polemical and no record permits a count of mita deaths as against deaths from the epidemics that struck the same populations.

Documented forms of violence

Forced LabourDestruction of PropertyCultural Destruction

The compulsory labour draft, the burning or abandonment of old settlements to prevent return, and the campaigns to extirpate Andean shrines that accompanied resettlement are documented in Toledo's own ordinances and inspection records and analysed in the University of Pennsylvania project and in Mumford's study.

Movements mapped

Countries touched, on present-day borders

Bolivia, Peru

Sources

← EarlierThe Dutch Revolt and the Exodus from the Southern Netherlands Later →The Spanish Reduccion and Resettlement of the Philippine Lowlands