Human Conflict Project

All events · Empire, Clearance and Removal

The Plains Wars and the United States Reservation and Allotment System

1851–1890 · Americas

Displacement Territory Seized
Territory
364,000 km²
Britannica records that of the 138 million acres held by tribes in 1887 when the Dawes General Allotment Act was passed, roughly two-thirds - about 90 million acres, or some 364,000 square km - had passed into white hands by 1932 through allotment, the sale of 'surplus' land and fraud. This is additional to the far larger areas ceded under the treaties of 1851-68 and to the seizure of the Black Hills after gold was found there in 1874.

Open on the interactive map →

What happened

Between the first Fort Laramie treaty of 1851 and the massacre at Wounded Knee in 1890, the United States converted the Great Plains from Native territory into reservations and then into settler property. Treaties assigned bounded territories and then reduced them; the 1868 Fort Laramie treaty guaranteed the Black Hills to the Oceti Sakowin, and the guarantee was broken after the gold rush of 1874. Military campaigns, the near-extermination of the bison herds on which Plains subsistence depended, and the withholding of rations enforced confinement. The Dawes General Allotment Act of 8 February 1887 then divided reservations into individual holdings of 80 to 160 acres and opened the remainder to sale: Britannica records that about two-thirds of the 138 million acres held in 1887 had been lost by 1932. Britannica dates the Plains Wars from the early 1850s to the late 1870s and the reservation and allotment regime carried the process into the twentieth century.

Parties

The United States confined the Native nations of the Great Plains to reservations by treaty and war, destroyed the bison herds, and then broke up the reservations under the Dawes Act

Disputed

Whether the treaties were negotiated with parties competent to cede the land, and the legal consequences of their breach, remain live: the Supreme Court held in 1980 that the taking of the Black Hills required just compensation, which the Oceti Sakowin have refused, seeking the land instead.

The denominator

There was no census of the Plains nations; the figure rests on Indian Office agency estimates and later reconstructions, which put the Plains tribes at roughly 100,000-250,000 in the mid-nineteenth century, with the Lakota, Cheyenne, Arapaho, Comanche, Kiowa, Crow, Blackfeet and the village peoples of the Missouri making up most of it. Smallpox and cholera epidemics of 1837 and 1849 had already cut the village nations severely.

Where the baseline comes from

On the death toll

No defensible aggregate death toll exists for four decades of intermittent campaigning across the Plains. Army returns record United States military casualties reasonably well and Native casualties badly; deaths from starvation and disease on the reservations after the bison collapse were not counted at all. The best-documented episodes - the Sand Creek and Wounded Knee massacres - are given separately, and adding them to unrecorded campaign and reservation mortality would produce a false precision.

Documented forms of violence

Destruction of PropertyStarvation and Siege

Britannica's accounts of the Plains Wars and the Fort Laramie treaties describe winter attacks on villages with the destruction of lodges, food stores and horse herds, and the use of ration control and the collapse of the bison herds to compel and maintain confinement on reservations.

Movements mapped

Countries touched, on present-day borders

United States of America

Related entries

Sources

This entry rests only on reference, press or open-edited sources. Treat its figures as indicative and follow the links before relying on them.
← EarlierThe Taiping Rebellion Later →Kanak Dispossession, the Reserves and the Evenements in New Caledonia